HP sigh

[jedi_of_urth]

So, because I could I wound up reading the TWoP HBP photo show and well...it reminded me why I hate that book.


All they seemed to talk about was the Hogwarts 90210 aspects, which I was really hoping they would tone down from the book. The plot of the book, though kind of thin, could have made up a good chuck of a movie length story without it having to give so much weight to the crappy ships of the book.

It was only my ability to hope that the 90210 aspects would be played down that had me all that interested in the movie, now that I'm back thinking they're going to make sure to sell that, and reminded of how much I hated it the first and only time I read the book, I'm back to not caring.

I will say that DH redeemed the series somewhat after the dren of HBP, but my love affair with the HP series died with HBP the first time around. Still, somehow I'm still worried the movie will manage to kill it more dead.

Comments

[jedi_of_urth]

I think the problem is that it was trying to combine the slap=slap-kiss cliche with R/Hr being supposed friends, which really isn't a good combination in my mind, so it got tangled around itself and yeah fell on its face. It really failed to convince me that they were really either without Harry which is why the only time I buy R/Hr is when it's part of the OT3 where Harry's the glue.

After the way OOTP set it up to be the sextet adventures, and fandom ran with it awesomely, the fact that Neville and Luna got virtually nothing to do in HBP made me angry. Less so in DH, especially since they were obviously off being awesome in their own story and the point of DH was to be about the Trio.

Not that I really liked DH either, but at least some of my problems with HBP were less glaring there. Some.

[tsukara.livejournal.com]

Yeah, with Harry it works. Without him, it's like pairing up the two sidekicks and thinking that should work fine. And it didn't.

That remains one of my favorite scenes in OotP, is the sextet fighting in the Ministry. Very cool, and she actually pulled it off (even if the reason they were there made me yell at Harry for being a dummy and the consequences were sad). And then she squished it.

DH...it was fine, and I had fewer issues with it--until she basically equated H/Hr shippers with Voldemort in that one scene. Then I (at first) got pissed, and then I decided it was so ridiculous the only reaction was to think the whole thing ridiculous and go from there. It worked out okay.

[jedi_of_urth]

Two sidekicks with very little in common, or connection outside of Harry. I mean, I love Willow/Xander and all, but they had their own relationship outside of Buffy whereas R/Hr is entirely formed round Harry.

Yeah, the sextet in the Ministry is great, and I feel like I should be kind of head smacky at Harry for falling for it because Harry is a far from perfect character. But that dynamic could have been the foundation for some awesome storytelling, but she just didn't go there, for reasons that I'm not wholly clear on, besides it not fitting with her outline which makes you wonder why she had it happen in the first place.

I've forgotten that part, I remember the "love her like a sister" bit which make me make faces at the book and have to walk away for a bit, until I just decided to laugh at it, because it was really just dumb. But as far as story structure I had fewer issues at least. Or I just cared less by then.