I read somewhere else today a point which is also relevant. D2, our human, happy with Rose version of the Doctor (I don't like the Ten II moinker that seems to be winning the popularity contests! Though I couldn't say why. Except I never like referring to the Doctor by number if it's not important to differentiate), never heard Davros's condemnation. He never had that moment of realization (as unfair as it is) that he hardens his companions and makes them killers.
I think that's particularly why the proper Doctor was so willing to give up Rose. Not just because he thought she deserved a 'normal' life with his duplicate, but because he didn't want to further damage her. And while his counterpart is possibly more damaged himself (hence Rose needing to fix him), he doesn't know this about himself (i mean, what Davros said) and since he'll never have a TARDIS or travelling companions or have the weight of the world on his shoulders, he won't do that to Rose.
If I had to pick a character to be mad at, though, I'd be mad at the proper Doctor. For thinking he knows what's best for everyone, and for basically denying himself happiness, for a shoddy reason at best. Though it's a little hard to be mad at someone who is so clearly devastated.
no subject
I think that's particularly why the proper Doctor was so willing to give up Rose. Not just because he thought she deserved a 'normal' life with his duplicate, but because he didn't want to further damage her. And while his counterpart is possibly more damaged himself (hence Rose needing to fix him), he doesn't know this about himself (i mean, what Davros said) and since he'll never have a TARDIS or travelling companions or have the weight of the world on his shoulders, he won't do that to Rose.
If I had to pick a character to be mad at, though, I'd be mad at the proper Doctor. For thinking he knows what's best for everyone, and for basically denying himself happiness, for a shoddy reason at best. Though it's a little hard to be mad at someone who is so clearly devastated.